We research and compare products using published specifications, features and owner feedback. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more›

4 Best Extra Large Mallet Putter Covers for Big Heads (2026)

Find the right extra large mallet putter cover. We compare four picks by fit, closure style, and material so you can protect an oversized putter head.

4 Best Extra Large Mallet Putter Covers for Big Heads (2026)

Updated November 2026

Shopping for an extra large mallet putter cover means finding one that stretches over an oversized head without sliding off mid-round. The four picks below are compared on fit for large mallet heads, closure type, material, and how well owners tend to describe them in feedback.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Oversized Golf Square Mallet Putter CoverTOP CHOICEBest overallOversized Golf Square Mallet Putter CoverView on Amazon
  2. 2Big Teeth Golf Putter Cover Mallet Golden RetrieverBest for playful stylingBig Teeth Golf Putter Cover Mallet Golden RetrieverView on Amazon
  3. 3Craftsman Golf Gorilla with Suits Mallet Putter CoverBest for gift-givingCraftsman Golf Gorilla with Suits Mallet Putter CoverView on Amazon
  4. 4Golf Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic StyleBest for a PU leather lookGolf Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic StyleView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Oversized Golf Square Mallet Putter Cover Large square-head putters Magnetic closure, two colors
Big Teeth Golf Putter Cover Mallet Golden Retriever Golfers who want a bold look Embroidered design, magnetic closure
Craftsman Golf Gorilla with Suits Mallet Putter Cover Gift buyers and novelty fans Character artwork, mallet fit
Golf Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Style Players wanting a leather-look cover PU leather, magnetic closure

Oversized Golf Square Mallet Putter Cover

Oversized Golf Square Mallet Putter Cover, 5.91 x 5.51 Inches Mallet Putter Headcover with Magnetic Closure, Black or White Golf Putter Head Cover (White)

Oversized Golf Square Mallet Putter Cover, 5.91 x 5.51 Inches Mallet Putter Headcover with Magnetic Closure, Black or White Golf Putter Head Cover (White)

View on Amazon

Best for: Large square-head putters that need extra room.

This cover suits golfers whose mallet heads are wider than standard headcovers can handle. The listing gives a 5.91 x 5.51 inch measurement, which is worth checking against your own putter before you buy.

Pros

  • Listed dimensions target oversized heads.
  • Magnetic closure keeps the cover secure.

Cons

  • Fit can feel snug on the tallest mallet designs.
View on Amazon

Big Teeth Golf Putter Cover Mallet Golden Retriever

Big Teeth Golf Putter Cover Mallet Golden Retriever, Heel Shaft Golf Square | Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Birdie Hunting Embroidered Headcover White

Big Teeth Golf Putter Cover Mallet Golden Retriever, Heel Shaft Golf Square | Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Birdie Hunting Embroidered Headcover White

View on Amazon

Best for: Golfers who want a playful, personality-driven look.

This embroidered cover is aimed at players who like a bit of character in their bag. It is a square-style mallet cover with a magnetic closure.

Pros

  • Embroidered artwork stands out on the course.
  • Magnetic closure makes removal quick.

Cons

  • Decorative stitching may show wear over time with heavy use.
View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf Gorilla with Suits Mallet Putter Cover

Craftsman Golf Gorilla with Suits Want to Take a Vacation Mallet Putter Cover Headcover

Craftsman Golf Gorilla with Suits Want to Take a Vacation Mallet Putter Cover Headcover

View on Amazon

Best for: Gift buyers and fans of novelty headcovers.

This character-themed cover works well as a gift or a conversation piece. It is built for mallet-style putters rather than blades.

Pros

  • Strong novelty appeal for gifting.
  • Designed specifically for mallet heads.

Cons

  • Artwork-focused designs are less of a priority for players who want a plain cover.
View on Amazon

Golf Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Style

Golf Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Style, Black or White Golf Putter Cover for Mallet Style Putters, PU Leather Mallet Headcover Protective Case fits for Odyssey 2 Ball, Stroke Lab (Black)

Golf Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Style, Black or White Golf Putter Cover for Mallet Style Putters, PU Leather Mallet Headcover Protective Case fits for Odyssey 2 Ball, Stroke Lab (Black)

View on Amazon

Best for: Players who want a leather-look cover with a magnetic closure.

This PU leather cover is listed as fitting several mallet models, including Odyssey-style putters. It comes in black or white.

Pros

  • PU leather finish looks clean with a range of putters.
  • Magnetic closure keeps it on securely.

Cons

  • Fit is listed for specific mallet shapes, so check your head size first.
View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Measure your putter head first

Measure the widest point of the head, from heel to toe, and the height from sole to crown. Compare these numbers with the listed dimensions before ordering, since oversized covers vary in fit.

Choose the closure style

Magnetic closures are common on mallet covers and make removal quick. Look for a secure hold so the cover does not shift during a swing.

Consider the material

PU leather gives a polished look, while embroidered or printed fabric covers lean toward style and personality. Pick the finish that matches how you want your bag to look.

Check the head shape

Square and rounded mallet heads need different cover shapes. A cover built for one shape may fit loosely or tightly on another.

Good picks for this: Oversized Golf Square Mallet Putter Cover and Golf Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Style

FAQ

How do I know if an extra large mallet putter cover will fit?

Compare your putter head’s width and height with the dimensions in the listing. A cover that is slightly larger than the head is usually the safer choice.

Are magnetic closures better than other types?

Magnetic closures are quick to use and keep the cover in place, which many golfers prefer. Other closure types can work well too, so choose based on how you like to handle your gear.

Can a cover damage my putter?

A properly fitted cover should not cause damage. Loose or abrasive covers can rub the finish over time, so check the fit and inspect the cover periodically.

Conclusion

For a large square-head putter, the Oversized Golf Square Mallet Putter Cover is the most direct fit for the search. Golfers who want a leather-look finish should consider the magnetic PU leather cover, while players after personality or a gift will find the other two picks more suitable.

Sources

Owen Palmer

About Owen Palmer

Owen Palmer is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our putting & short game guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.

About the author

Owen Palmer
Owen Palmer

Owen Palmer writes reviews and buying guides for Putting For Par.