Odyssey Mallet Putter Used: 4 Best Picks Compared (2026)
Looking for an odyssey mallet putter used? Compare four well-regarded Odyssey options by fit, feel and alignment so you can buy with confidence.
Updated November 2026
Shopping for an odyssey mallet putter used can save money, but condition, fit and model matter more than the sticker. This list compares four Odyssey mallet models based on product listings, brand reputation and common owner feedback. The criteria are shaft length, face insert feel, alignment aids and how forgiving the head is on off-center strikes.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallOdyssey Golf DFX Putter (Right Hand (2025), 35 Inches, V Line Fang, Oversized Grip)View on Amazon - 2
Best for alignmentOdyssey Square to Square Putter (Right Hand, 33 Inches, Jailbird)View on Amazon - 3
Best for a bold lookOdyssey Turtle PutterView on Amazon - 4
Best for max forgivenessOdyssey Golf S2S AI-Dual Putter (Right Hand,35 Inches,Max 1/2 Ball,Center Shaft)View on Amazon
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Odyssey Golf DFX Putter | Well-rounded everyday use | V Line fang, oversized grip |
| Odyssey Turtle Putter | Players who want a distinctive look | Turtle-shell head design |
| Odyssey Square to Square Putter | Alignment-focused golfers | Square-to-square alignment aid |
| Odyssey Golf S2S AI-Dual Putter | Forgiveness on off-center hits | Dual face insert, center shaft |
Odyssey Golf DFX Putter (Right Hand (2025), 35 Inches, V Line Fang, Oversized Grip)
Best for: Well-rounded everyday use
This model suits golfers who want a traditional mallet feel with a stable, easy-to-read setup. The 35-inch length works for many standard builds, and the oversized grip helps players with a lighter touch.
Pros
- Clean V Line fang that aids aim
- Oversized grip reduces wrist action
Cons
- Standard length may need adjusting for shorter players
Odyssey Turtle Putter
Best for: Players who want a distinctive look
Owners who like a bold, shaped head and enjoy a putter that stands out at address will appreciate this one. It is a better fit for golfers comfortable with a more visually active design.
Pros
- Eye-catching head shape
- Solid mallet weighting for smooth roll
Cons
- Unusual shape can take time to trust for alignment
Odyssey Square to Square Putter (Right Hand, 33 Inches, Jailbird)
Best for: Alignment-focused golfers
This is a good match for players who struggle with face angle at setup. The square-to-square alignment cues help golfers keep the putter face consistent from the backstroke through impact.
Pros
- Strong alignment reference lines
- 33-inch length suits shorter players
Cons
- Shorter length may feel cramped for taller golfers
Odyssey Golf S2S AI-Dual Putter (Right Hand,35 Inches,Max 1/2 Ball,Center Shaft)
Best for: Forgiveness on off-center hits
Golfers who miss the sweet spot often will benefit from the dual insert and center-shaft setup. Owners commonly report more consistent distance on mishits, which makes it a practical choice for higher-handicap putting.
Pros
- Dual insert helps on off-center strikes
- Center shaft promotes a stable stroke path
Cons
- Larger head can look bulky to players who prefer compact designs
Buying Guide
Check the condition of the face insert
Look for dents, pitting or wear on the insert, since these affect feel and roll. Ask the seller for close-up photos of the face before you commit.
Confirm the shaft length and lie
Length should suit your height and posture, so a putter that feels right at address will be more consistent. If you are unsure, a fitting session is a good idea.
Look at alignment features
Lines, fangs and sight markers can help you square the face, but they only help if they match how you aim. Try them in a quick setup before you decide.
Verify grip wear and shaft straightness
A worn grip changes hand position, and a bent shaft changes face angle. Roll the shaft on a flat surface and inspect the grip before buying.
Good picks for this: Odyssey Square to Square Putter and Odyssey Golf DFX Putter
FAQ
Is a used Odyssey mallet putter worth buying?
Yes, if the face insert, shaft and grip are in good condition. Used putters often offer strong value because the core design remains the same.
How do I know the right putter length?
A common approach is to stand naturally with the putter at your eye line and check that your hands hang comfortably. Many golfers do better with a fitting before buying used.
Should I replace the grip on a used putter?
If the grip is hard, slick or worn, replacing it is an inexpensive way to restore feel. Consider a grip change if your hands slip during the stroke.
Conclusion
The Odyssey Golf DFX Putter fits most everyday players, while the Square to Square suits golfers who need strong alignment cues. Choose the Turtle for a distinctive look and the S2S AI-Dual if off-center hits are a frequent problem.
Sources
- Rules of golf and equipment standards for putters
- Equipment conformance guidance and club specifications
Related reading
- Odyssey White Hot RX Mallet Putter: 5 Best Options Compared (2026)
- Odyssey Mid Mallet Putter: 5 Best Picks Compared (2026)
- 5 Best Odyssey White Ice Mallet Putter Options for Every Stroke (2026)
- 5 Best Odyssey White Hot Mallet Putter Options Compared (2026)
- 5 Best Odyssey 7 Mallet Putter Options for Every Stroke (2026)
- 4 Best Odyssey Red Mallet Putter Options Compared (2026)
