7 Best Mallet Style Putter Covers (2026): Our Picks
Find the best mallet putter cover for your stroke. We compare seven options by fit, closure, material and protection so you can choose with confidence.
Updated November 2026
A mallet style putter cover protects a large, often painted or milled head from scratches, dings and the wear that comes from sliding into a crowded bag. The right one should fit snugly without straining the seams, close securely, and suit the shape of your putter, whether it has a heel shaft, a center shaft or a square profile. The picks below were chosen from product listings, brand reputation and common owner feedback, weighing fit, closure type, material and build quality.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallDo Not 3 PUTT Putter Headcovers Golf Mallet Putter Cover Blade Putter CoverView on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for magnetic closureUSA Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Golf Head CoversView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for square headsMallet Putter Cover Headcover Heel Shaft Mallet Cover SquareView on Amazon - 4
Best for all-black looksGolf Putter Cover Square Mallet Putter Head Cover Magnetic All BlackView on Amazon - 5
Best for a budget pickMontela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover Blade Putter CoversView on Amazon - 6
Best for gift-ready setsMallet Putter Head Cover USA Flag PU Leather Golf Putter HeadcoverView on Amazon - 7
Best for quick, easy fitZEETY Putter Cover, Mallet & Blade Putter Cover, Magnetic Golf HeadcovView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Do Not 3 PUTT Putter Headcovers | Overall protection | Broad mallet fit |
| USA Mallet Putter Cover Headcover | Secure closure | Magnetic closure |
| Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Square | Square heads | Heel shaft design |
| Golf Putter Cover Square Mallet | Classic black look | All-black magnetic |
| Montela Golf Putter Covers | Budget buyers | Simple value build |
| Mallet Putter Head Cover USA Flag | Gift-ready style | PU leather finish |
| ZEETY Putter Cover Mallet & Blade | Fast, easy fitting | Tap-in magnetic fit |
Do Not 3 PUTT Putter Headcovers Golf Mallet Putter Cover Blade Putter Cover
Best for: Overall protection across mallet shapes
This suits golfers who want one cover that handles a range of mallet heads without much fuss.
Pros
- Designed to cover a wide range of mallet profiles
- Protective padding helps guard against bag contact
Cons
- Fit can feel looser on compact heads
USA Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Golf Head Covers
USA Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Magnetic Golf Head Covers Headcovers Club Protective Equipment for Scotty Cameron Odyssey Two Ball Taylormade Durable
Best for: Secure, quick-release closure
A good fit for golfers who take their covers on and off often and want the head held firmly in place.
Pros
- Magnetic closure keeps the flap in place during play
- Easy one-handed removal before a stroke
Cons
- Magnets can be weaker than snap-style closures over time
Mallet Putter Cover Headcover Heel Shaft Mallet Cover Square
Mallet Putter Cover Headcover,Heel Shaft Mallet Cover Square with Magnetic Closure & USA Stars and Stripes
Best for: Square-profile heads with a heel shaft
Built with square-head geometry in mind, this one suits golfers with boxier putters.
Pros
- Shape matches square mallet outlines
- Magnetic closure with a clean, simple look
Cons
- Less suited to rounded or deep-face heads
Golf Putter Cover Square Mallet Putter Head Cover Magnetic All Black
Golf Putter Cover Square Mallet Putter Head Cover Magnetic All Black(Black) | All Black, Red Blue White Patriotism Style Mallet Headcover for Men Golfer
Best for: A clean, all-black look
Golfers who prefer a understated bag and a matching black head cover will find this one appealing.
Pros
- Consistent all-black finish matches most bag setups
- Magnetic closure for quick access
Cons
- Dark finish shows lint and dust more readily
Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover Blade Putter Covers
Best for: Budget-minded golfers
A practical option for golfers who want basic protection without paying for extras.
Pros
- Simple, no-frills build that does the core job
- Works for mallet putters and blades alike
Cons
- Materials feel lighter than premium leather options
Mallet Putter Head Cover USA Flag PU Leather Golf Putter Headcover
Mallet Putter Head Cover, USA Flag PU Leather Golf Putter Headcover with Magnetic Closure, Bundle with 10 Pack USA Flag Golf Tees, Fits Odyssey Scotty Cameron Heel Shaft & Center Shaft Mallet Putters
Best for: Gift-ready style and a patriotic look
This suits golfers who want a visible, decorative cover and like the bundled accessories.
Pros
- PU leather finish with a distinctive flag design
- Bundle includes golf tees, useful for a gift
Cons
- Bold design may not suit every golfer’s taste
Buying Guide
Fit and Head Shape
Start by measuring the shape of your putter head, since mallet heads come in square, rounded and wide profiles. A cover that is too tight can strain the seams, while one that is too loose will slide around and fail to protect the face. Check whether the cover is designed for a heel shaft or a center shaft, because the shaft opening position changes the fit.
Closure Type
Most mallet covers use either a magnetic closure or a hook-and-loop or tab closure. Magnetic closures are quick to use and keep the cover secure during a round, but make sure the magnets are strong enough to hold without pulling the cover off the head. Consider how often you plan to remove the cover on the course.
Material and Durability
Synthetic leather and PU leather are popular because they resist moisture and wear well over time. Look for stitching that is reinforced at stress points and an interior lining that will not scratch a painted or milled finish. A durable build matters most if your bag is often packed tightly or carried on a cart.
Protection and Coverage
Think about how much of the head the cover protects. Full-coverage designs guard the face, sole and hosel area, while lighter designs may leave parts exposed. If you value protection against bag scuffs and course debris, choose a cover that wraps around the full head rather than just the face.
FAQ
Will a mallet putter cover fit my putter?
It depends on the head shape and shaft position of your putter. Measure the head width, depth and height, and check whether the cover is labeled for heel shaft or center shaft designs. A snug fit is best for protection without straining the seams.
Are magnetic closures strong enough to stay on during a round?
Magnetic closures on quality covers are generally secure enough for normal play. They allow quick removal before putting and reattachment afterward. Check the cover’s design to make sure the magnets sit in the right place for your putter.
What material holds up best over time?
PU leather and synthetic leather tend to resist moisture and abrasion better than basic fabric. Reinforced stitching adds to long-term durability. Materials matter most if you carry your bag on a cart or store it in a crowded space.
Can a putter cover protect against scratches in the bag?
Yes, a well-fitted cover reduces contact between the putter head and other clubs, which helps prevent scuffs, dings and paint wear. Full-coverage designs offer the most protection. Keep the interior lining clean so grit does not work against the finish.
Should I buy a cover for a blade putter as well?
Some covers are designed for both mallet and blade shapes, but mallet-specific covers usually fit better on larger heads. If you own both styles, check whether the product lists compatibility with each. Matching the cover to the head shape gives the best protection.
Conclusion
If you want the strongest all-around protection and a secure fit for a standard mallet, the Do Not 3 PUTT cover is a solid choice. For players who prefer a quick magnetic closure, the USA Mallet Putter Cover or the ZEETY cover are good options to consider, depending on your putter shape.
Related reading
- Texas Longhorns Mallet Putter Cover: How to Choose One That Fits (2026)
- Tennessee Mallet Putter Cover: How to Choose and Fit One (2026)
- Small Mallet Putter Cover: 7 Best Picks for Every Stroke (2026)
- Premium Mallet Putter Cover: Is It Worth the Extra Cost?
- Mid Mallet Putter Cover UK: How to Choose One That Fits (2026)
