6 Best Mid Size Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)

Updated November 2026

A mid size mallet putter cover protects a putter head that falls between the compact half-mallet and the full-sized mallet shapes, and it has to fit snugly enough to stay on through a bag full of clubs. Golfers searching for a mid size mallet putter cover usually want three things: a close fit that does not slide off the head, a closure that holds well (most often magnetic or a strap), and materials that stand up to rain, sand and sun. The six picks below were chosen by reviewing product specifications, brand reputation and the patterns owners report about fit, closure strength and durability. None of them were physically tested for this article.

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product	Best for	Key feature
USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head Cover	Overall fit with most brands	Magnetic closure
mytag Jason Mask Golf Putter Cover, Half Mallet Putter Cover	Heel shaft and blade putters	Mask-style design for mid mallet and blade heads
Big Teeth Golf US Design Mid Mallet Putter Cover	Budget-conscious buyers	Magnetic closure in black and gray
Craftsman Golf Club Head Covers Driver Headcovers Set	Golfers who want matching covers	Set design covering driver, woods and putter
Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, Blue	Center shaft putters	Soft leather with embroidery
Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Small Mallet Putter Cover Strong Magnetic	Players who want a secure closure	Strong magnets and waterproof PU leather

USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head Cover

Best for: Overall fit across most putter brands

This cover suits golfers who want a single, versatile mid mallet headcover that works across several putter makes. Its half and small mallet labeling signals a mid-sized profile rather than a full mallet shape.

Key specs

• Style: Mid mallet / half mallet headcover
• Closure: Magnetic
• Fit: Listed as fitting most golf brands

Pros

• Magnetic closure keeps the cover on during swings and bag movement
• Broad fit listing across brands
• Printed design is easy to spot in a bag

Cons

• Print designs can show wear sooner than solid colors, according to some owners
• Fit can vary on putters with unusually sized heads

Bottom line: A good first choice for golfers who want a dependable, all-around mid mallet cover with a magnetic closure.

View on Amazon

mytag Jason Mask Golf Putter Cover, Half Mallet Putter Cover

Best for: Heel shaft and blade putters that need a mid mallet style fit

This cover is listed for mid mallet, heel shaft, center shaft and blade putters, making it a useful option for golfers whose putter shape does not match a standard mallet cover.

Key specs

• Style: Half mallet putter cover
• Listed compatibility: Mid mallet, heel shaft, center shaft and blade putters

Pros

• Wide compatibility listing across putter types
• Mask-style design gives a distinctive look
• Half mallet profile suits compact heads

Cons

• Broad compatibility can mean a looser fit on some heads
• Owners who prefer strong magnets may want a different closure

Bottom line: Best for players who switch between blade and mid mallet putters and want one cover that bridges both shapes.

View on Amazon

Big Teeth Golf US Design Mid Mallet Putter Cover, Small Mallet Putter Cover

Best for: Budget-conscious golfers who want a magnetic cover

A solid choice for golfers who want a dependable magnetic mid mallet cover without paying for premium leather. It is listed as fitting popular putter models such as Odyssey White Hot and Scotty Cameron.

Key specs

• Style: Mid mallet / small mallet putter cover
• Closure: Magnetic
• Color: Black and gray

Pros

• Magnetic closure is straightforward to use
• Neutral black and gray color suits most bags
• Listed compatibility with several popular putter lines

Cons

• Material feel is lighter than leather options
• Fit may be looser on some head shapes

Bottom line: A practical, budget-minded cover for golfers who want a simple magnetic closure and a clean look.

View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf Club Head Covers Driver Headcovers Set

Best for: Golfers who want matching covers for the whole bag

This set includes covers for drivers, fairway woods and hybrids, plus a putter cover listed for mallet, mid mallet and blade shapes. It suits players who prefer a coordinated look across their clubs.

Key specs

• Format: Multi-cover set
• Putter listing: DF3, OZ1, mallet, mid mallet and blade
• Color: Classic brown

Pros

• Full set covers the whole bag in one purchase
• Coordinated design across club types
• Putter cover is listed for several head shapes

Cons

• Putter cover fit may be less precise than a single-purpose cover
• Not ideal if you only need a putter cover

Bottom line: Best for golfers building a matching headcover set who want a mid mallet putter cover included.

View on Amazon

Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, Blue

Best for: Center shaft putters that need a snug, premium-feeling cover

Designed for center shaft mid and half mallet putters, this cover emphasizes soft leather and embroidery, making it a good match for golfers who want a more finished look.

Key specs

• Style: Center shaft mid/half mallet
• Closure: Magnetic
• Material: Soft leather with embroidery

Pros

• Soft leather feels more premium than basic synthetic covers
• Embroidery adds a finished look
• Center shaft specific sizing

Cons

• Leather needs occasional care to stay in good shape
• Less suited to golfers with heel shaft putters

Bottom line: The right pick for center shaft putter owners who want a soft, well-finished magnetic cover.

View on Amazon

Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Small Mallet Putter Cover Strong Magnetic

Best for: Players who want a secure closure that resists falling off

This cover emphasizes a strong magnetic closure and waterproof PU leather, which suits golfers who play in wet conditions or who have had covers slip off during the round.

Key specs

• Style: Mid mallet / small mallet
• Closure: Strong magnetic
• Material: Black PU leather, waterproof

Pros

• Strong magnetic closure for a secure hold
• Waterproof PU leather handles rain well
• Listed for popular putter brands

Cons

• Strong magnets can make removal feel stiff on some heads
• PU leather is less breathable than fabric designs

Bottom line: A strong pick for golfers who prioritize a tight, weather-resistant cover over a softer feel.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Fit and head shape

Measure the head length and depth of your putter before buying. A mid mallet cover should sit flush against the crown without bulging. If the cover is too loose, the putter can shift inside it during the bag ride. Check whether a listing names your exact model or just a broad category.

Good picks for this: USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head Cover, mytag Jason Mask Golf Putter Cover

Closure type

Magnetic closures are the most common choice for mid mallet covers because they are quick to use. Strong magnets hold better in wind and rough cart travel, but they can make removal feel stiff. Strap or hook-and-loop closures are an alternative if you want a fixed hold.

Good picks for this: Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Strong Magnetic, Big Teeth Golf US Design Mid Mallet Putter Cover

Shaft type

Center shaft, heel shaft and blade putters have different head geometry, so a cover built for one may not fit another. Look for center shaft specific listings if your putter has a centered hosel, and check compatibility notes on heel shaft models.

Good picks for this: Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, mytag Jason Mask Golf Putter Cover

Material and weather resistance

Soft leather feels premium and ages well with care. PU leather resists water and is easy to wipe clean. Fabric and printed designs are lighter but can show wear faster. If you play in rain or sand often, favor waterproof materials.

Good picks for this: Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Strong Magnetic, Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover

Use case and bag setup

If you carry a full matching set, a coordinated headcover set may suit you better than buying one putter cover. If you only need protection for the putter, a single-purpose cover usually gives a more precise fit.

Good picks for this: Craftsman Golf Club Head Covers Driver Headcovers Set, USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head Cover

Durability and care

Owners commonly report that magnetic covers last longest when they are wiped after wet rounds and stored dry. Leather benefits from occasional conditioning, while printed designs should be kept out of prolonged sun exposure. Replace a cover if the magnets weaken, since a weak closure is the most common reason a cover falls off.

Good picks for this: Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, Big Teeth Golf US Design Mid Mallet Putter Cover

Budget and value

A budget pick can protect your putter well if the fit is right. Spend more when the material, stitching or closure matters to you. The best value is a cover that fits your head shape precisely, since a poor fit is the main reason golfers replace covers early.

Good picks for this: Big Teeth Golf US Design Mid Mallet Putter Cover, mytag Jason Mask Golf Putter Cover

FAQ

What is a mid size mallet putter cover?

It is a protective headcover shaped for a putter head that sits between a half mallet and a full mallet. It protects the face and finish while the club is in the bag.

How do I know if a mid mallet cover will fit my putter?

Compare your putter’s head length, depth and shaft location to the cover’s listed compatibility. A snug fit without bulging is the goal. If the listing is vague, check reviews from owners of the same putter model.

Are magnetic closures better than strap closures?

Magnetic closures are quicker to use and hold well for most golfers. Straps can provide a more fixed hold. The better choice depends on how often you remove the cover and how rough your bag handling is.

Can one headcover fit center shaft and heel shaft putters?

Some covers are listed for multiple shaft types, but fit can vary. Center shaft specific covers are usually more precise for center shaft putters, so check the listing notes before buying.

How should I clean a leather putter cover?

Wipe it with a soft, slightly damp cloth and let it air dry away from direct heat. Use a leather conditioner sparingly if the manufacturer recommends one. Avoid soaking it.

Do I need a matching headcover set?

No. A set is convenient if you want coordinated covers for the whole bag. If you only need putter protection, a single mid mallet cover is usually enough.

When should I replace a putter cover?

Replace it when the magnets no longer hold, the stitching or leather is splitting, or the fit has loosened so the cover slips off during the round.

Conclusion

For most golfers, the USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head Cover is a sensible starting point because of its magnetic closure and broad fit listing. Center shaft owners should look at the soft leather option, while players who want a secure, weather-resistant hold will favor the strong magnetic Shamrock cover. Budget-minded golfers can consider the Big Teeth Golf design, and those building a matching bag should look at the Craftsman set. The right choice comes down to fit first, then closure and material.

Sources

• Official rules and equipment standards that govern golf club dimensions and putter design
• General guidance on golf equipment fit and club design
• Consumer safety information on magnets and small magnetic components (cpsc.gov)

Related reading

• 7 Best Scotty Cameron Mid Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)
• 6 Best Mid Mallet Putter Covers for Every Golfer (2026)
• 3 Best Mid Mallet Putter Cover Magnetic Options for Every Stroke (2026)
• Small Mallet Putter Cover: 7 Best Picks for Every Stroke (2026)
• Mid Mallet Putter Headcovers: 6 Fit Factors That Matter (2026)

About the author