6 Best Headcovers Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)

Updated November 2026

Shopping for a headcovers mallet putter cover is less about finding the flashiest design and more about matching fit, closure and material to how you actually carry and use your putter. A cover that slides on loosely will shift during the round, a magnetic flap that won’t hold will pop open in your bag, and a fabric that traps moisture can leave your head dirty or worse. The six picks below were chosen by comparing manufacturer specifications, brand reputation for mallet fit, and the patterns owners tend to mention in feedback about closure, stitching and shaft compatibility. We did not test these covers ourselves; this is a research-based list built to help you narrow the field quickly.

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product	Best for	Key feature
Mallet Putter Cover Headcover, Heel Shaft Mallet Cover Square	Heel shaft mallets with a square profile	Magnetic closure and USA-themed design
Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover	Golfers who want a plain black cover	Simple black styling for mallet heads
Craftsman Golf Club Cover Mallet Putter Headcover	Golfers who want visibility in the bag	Green and white checkered pattern with magnetic closure
Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover Headcover	Heel shaft putters in the Scotty Cameron style	Heel shaft fit with patriotic graphics
Mallet Putter Head Cover, USA Flag PU Leather Golf Putter Headcover	Heel and center shaft mallets	PU leather build with magnetic closure
Golf Putter Cover, Mallet Putter Headcover Mesh	Budget-minded golfers and open-mesh breathability	Mesh construction with magic tape closure

Mallet Putter Cover Headcover, Heel Shaft Mallet Cover Square

Best for: Heel shaft mallet owners who want a snug, square-profile cover with a secure closure.

This cover suits golfers whose putter has a squared-off head and a heel-mounted shaft. The magnetic closure is the main draw, keeping the flap shut during a walk or cart ride.

Key specs

• Designed for heel shaft mallet putters
• Square-profile cut
• Magnetic closure
• USA stars and stripes design

Pros

• Magnetic closure holds the flap securely
• Square profile fits many heel shaft mallets
• Patriotic design stands out in a bag

Cons

• Fit can vary on heads that are not square
• Owners with center shaft putters will need another option

Bottom line: A strong pick for heel shaft mallet owners who want a magnetic closure and a square fit.

View on Amazon

Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover

Best for: Golfers who want a simple, understated black cover.

This is a good fit for players who prefer a clean black look and want a cover that doesn’t draw attention. It is listed for mallet putters, so check your head shape before ordering.

Key specs

• Black colorway
• Designed for mallet putter heads

Pros

• Understated black finish blends into any bag
• Straightforward design with no distracting graphics
• Good choice for a matching set with black or dark putters

Cons

• Plain design offers no visual cue for identifying your putter
• Fit details are limited in the listing, so measuring your head is advisable

Bottom line: Ideal for golfers who want a plain black mallet cover without extra styling.

View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf Club Cover Mallet Putter Headcover

Best for: Golfers who want their putter to stand out in the bag.

The green and white checkered pattern makes this cover easy to spot among a group of identical bags. The magnetic closure adds convenience at the course.

Key specs

• Green and white checkered pattern
• Magnetic closure
• Designed for mallet putter heads

Pros

• Highly visible pattern helps you spot your putter quickly
• Magnetic closure is quick to open and close
• Playful look suits casual rounds

Cons

• Bold pattern may not suit formal or conservative tastes
• Check head dimensions, as fit varies across mallet shapes

Bottom line: A good choice for golfers who value visibility and a fun look.

View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover Headcover

Best for: Owners of heel shaft mallets in the Scotty Cameron style who want a patriotic design.

This cover is listed for heel shaft putters and is aimed at golfers whose mallet has a similar profile to popular Scotty Cameron heads.

Key specs

• Designed for heel shaft mallet putters
• USA America graphic design

Pros

• Clear heel shaft orientation simplifies fitting
• Patriotic graphics are distinctive
• Works as a conversation starter on the course

Cons

• Not suited to center shaft putters
• Fit is specific to certain head shapes, so confirm dimensions first

Bottom line: Best for heel shaft mallet owners who want a distinctive patriotic cover.

View on Amazon

Mallet Putter Head Cover, USA Flag PU Leather Golf Putter Headcover

Best for: Golfers with either heel or center shaft mallets who want a leather-look cover with a magnetic closure.

The PU leather construction gives this cover a more substantial feel than mesh or thin fabric, and the listing states it fits both heel and center shaft mallets, which broadens its appeal.

Key specs

• PU leather construction
• Magnetic closure
• USA flag design
• Listed for heel shaft and center shaft mallet putters

Pros

• Leather-look material feels more durable than mesh
• Covers both heel and center shaft listings
• Magnetic closure keeps the cover in place

Cons

• PU leather can feel warmer in hot weather than mesh
• Owners report that fit should be checked against specific head dimensions

Bottom line: A versatile pick for golfers with either shaft style who want a sturdier cover.

View on Amazon

Golf Putter Cover, Mallet Putter Headcover Mesh Golf Putter Head Cover

Best for: Budget-minded golfers who want a breathable cover for heel shaft mallets.

Mesh covers allow air to move around the head, which helps reduce moisture buildup after wet rounds. The magic tape closure is simple and inexpensive to maintain.

Key specs

• Mesh construction
• Magic tape closure
• Listed for heel shaft mallet putters including Odyssey and Scotty Cameron styles

Pros

• Breathable mesh helps head dry out
• Lightweight and easy to store
• Straightforward closure with no magnets

Cons

• Mesh offers less protection against scratches than leather-look materials
• Magic tape can lose grip over time with frequent use

Bottom line: A practical choice for golfers on a tighter budget who want breathability and easy handling.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Shaft Position: Heel vs. Center

Check whether your mallet has a heel shaft or a center shaft before buying. A heel shaft cover is shaped to wrap around an offset neck, while a center shaft cover accounts for the shaft entering the middle of the head. Measure your head width and depth and compare them with the listed dimensions. For a full walkthrough, see Center Shafted Mallet Putter Headcovers: How to Choose and Fit One (2026).

Good picks for this: Mallet Putter Head Cover, USA Flag PU Leather; Mallet Putter Cover Headcover, Heel Shaft Mallet Cover Square

Closure Type

Magnetic closures are quick to use and keep the flap shut during a walk. Magic tape is inexpensive and simple but can lose grip over many rounds. Check that the closure does not catch on your glove or bag interior. For the magnetic option in more depth, read 7 Best Magnetic Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026).

Good picks for this: Craftsman Golf Club Cover Mallet Putter Headcover; Golf Putter Cover, Mallet Putter Headcover Mesh

Material

PU leather-look covers feel sturdier and resist scuffing better than mesh, but they hold more heat. Mesh breathes well and dries quickly after wet conditions. Neoprene and fabric options sit in between. If you are considering a premium material, Premium Mallet Putter Cover: Is It Worth the Extra Cost? explains the trade-offs.

Good picks for this: Mallet Putter Head Cover, USA Flag PU Leather; Golf Putter Cover, Mallet Putter Headcover Mesh

Size and Fit

A good fit should slide on without forcing and stay put without a loose gap at the toe. Measure the head’s length, width and depth, then compare them with the cover’s listed dimensions. Owners often report that covers designed for a specific brand fit that brand best, so measurements matter more than the label. Start with Golf Mallet Putter Headcovers: How to Choose and Fit the Right One (2026) for a measuring checklist.

Good picks for this: Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover Headcover; Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover

Visibility and Style

If you carry a bag with several putters or share a cart, a bright or patterned cover makes your putter easy to identify. Plain black covers suit golfers who prefer a clean look. Pick a style that you will still like after many rounds.

Good picks for this: Craftsman Golf Club Cover Mallet Putter Headcover; Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover

Durability and Stitching

Look for reinforced seams and a closure that will not tear out when you pull the cover off. Owners often note that stitching is the first place covers fail, especially around the closure and the shaft opening. Inspect a cover after a few rounds and replace it if seams begin to split.

Good picks for this: Mallet Putter Head Cover, USA Flag PU Leather; Mallet Putter Cover Headcover, Heel Shaft Mallet Cover Square

Care and Maintenance

Remove the cover after wet rounds and let it air dry away from direct heat. Wipe PU leather-look covers with a damp cloth and mild soap, and avoid soaking them. Mesh covers can be rinsed and dried quickly. Keeping the cover clean prevents grit from scratching your putter face.

Good picks for this: Golf Putter Cover, Mallet Putter Headcover Mesh; Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover Headcover

FAQ

How do I know if a headcover fits my mallet putter?

Measure the head’s length, width and depth, plus the shaft opening position. Compare these with the cover’s listed dimensions. A snug fit with no gap at the toe is the goal.

What is the difference between heel and center shaft covers?

Heel shaft covers wrap around an offset hosel near the heel of the head. Center shaft covers are shaped for a shaft that enters the middle of the head. Using the wrong style will cause the cover to sit crooked or fall off.

Are magnetic closures better than magic tape?

Magnetic closures are faster to open and close and tend to stay shut. Magic tape is simpler and cheaper but can lose grip after many uses. Choose based on how often you plan to change covers.

Can I wash a mallet putter cover?

Most covers can be wiped clean with a damp cloth and mild soap. Mesh covers can be rinsed. Let any cover air dry fully before putting it back on your putter, and avoid heat sources.

Will a headcover protect my putter from scratches?

A cover reduces contact damage in your bag, but it does not stop all wear. Thicker materials such as PU leather-look covers generally offer more protection than thin mesh.

Should I buy a cover for a blade putter too?

Blade putters use different cover styles. If you own both types, check the product listing for the intended head style before buying. See Small Mallet Putter Cover: 7 Best Picks for Every Stroke (2026) for comparisons of smaller mallet shapes.

How often should I replace my cover?

Replace a cover when seams split, the closure no longer holds, or the material shows heavy scuffing. Owners often report needing a new cover after a season of heavy use.

Conclusion

For heel shaft mallets with a secure closure, the Mallet Putter Cover Headcover in the square heel shaft style is a strong starting point. Golfers with either shaft style who want a sturdier material will find the USA Flag PU Leather option versatile. The Golf Putter Cover mesh model suits budget-minded players who value breathability, while the Craftsman checkered cover is the choice for anyone who wants their putter to stand out. Match the cover to your head’s shaft position and dimensions first, then choose the material and closure that suit how you play.

Sources

• Official rules and equipment standards for golf clubs and accessories, including guidance relevant to club fitting
• Rules and equipment information from the R&A, the governing body for golf outside the United States and Mexico
• Instruction and equipment fitting articles from the PGA of America

Related reading

• Scotty Cameron Mallet Putter Headcover: 5 Best Picks for Every Stroke (2026)

About the author