6 Best Scotty Cameron Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)

Updated November 2026

Scotty Cameron mallet putter covers protect a putter head that often costs more than the rest of your bag, and the right cover also helps you spot the correct head when it sits in a crowded cart bag or on a shop shelf. This list is built on the criteria that matter most when you shop: model-specific fit, shaft type (center or heel), magnetic closure, build quality, and how consistently owners report the cover staying on the head through a round. Each pick is a real Amazon listing, and the notes below explain who each cover suits.

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product	Best for	Key feature
Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover	Center shaft mid mallets	Center shaft fit, Phantom styling
New Scotty Cameron Gray MID Mallet Cover Putter Headcover	Gray mid mallet owners	Universal mid mallet fit
Scotty Cameron Authentic Putter Headcover – Futura, Phantom X	Right-handed Futura and Phantom X heads	Multi-size model listing
New Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover	Newer mid-mallet styles	Mid-mallet profile, not blade
USA Mallet Putter Cover Magnetic Headcover	Owners wanting a magnetic closure	Magnetic closure, broad fit
Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover	Heel shaft putters	Designed for heel shaft heads

Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover

Best for: Golfers with a center shaft mid mallet who want an authentic, model-matched cover.

This cover suits players who own a Phantom-style mid mallet with a center shaft and want the head protected without guessing about fit. The listing is specifically sized for center shaft use.

Key specs

• Designed for center shaft putters
• Mid mallet profile
• Black, gray and red colorway

Pros

• Listed as authentic Scotty Cameron product
• Center shaft specific fit
• Matches the Phantom mid mallet styling

Cons

• Only suits center shaft heads
• Fit is narrower than universal covers

Bottom line: The first choice for a center shaft Phantom mid mallet owner who wants the most specific fit.

View on Amazon

New Scotty Cameron Gray MID Mallet Cover Putter Headcover

Best for: Owners of gray mid mallet heads who want a universal, authentic-listed cover.

This cover is aimed at players whose mid mallet is gray and who want a cover that fits a range of mid-mallet shapes rather than one exact model.

Key specs

• Mid mallet profile
• Gray colorway
• Listed as universal fit

Pros

• Universal mid-mallet fit
• Simple gray styling
• Listed as authentic

Cons

• Universal fit can feel looser than model-specific covers
• Limited color options

Bottom line: A solid pick for gray mid mallet owners who want flexibility across head shapes.

View on Amazon

Scotty Cameron Authentic Putter Headcover – Futura, Phantom X

Best for: Right-handed owners of Futura or Phantom X heads in several sizes.

This listing covers multiple Scotty Cameron head models, so it suits golfers who want one cover for a Futura or Phantom X and are right-handed.

Key specs

• Fits Futura and Phantom X models
• Listed for right-handed use
• Mid round head profile

Pros

• Covers several Futura and Phantom X sizes
• Authentic-listed Scotty Cameron product
• Clear model compatibility

Cons

• Right-handed only
• Size selection must be checked carefully

Bottom line: Best for right-handed Futura or Phantom X owners who want one listing that covers more than one head.

View on Amazon

New Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover

Best for: Owners of newer mid-mallet styles who want a cover that matches the 2025 look.

This cover is intended for mid mallets rather than blades, making it a fit for golfers whose current putter follows the newer mid-mallet profile.

Key specs

• Mid-mallet profile, not blade
• Style 2025 design
• Listed as authentic

Pros

• Designed for current mid-mallet styles
• Clearly labeled as mid-mallet, not blade
• Listed as authentic

Cons

• Not suitable for blade putters
• Newer design may not match older heads

Bottom line: Pick this if your mid mallet is a newer Scotty Cameron style and you want a matching cover.

View on Amazon

USA Mallet Putter Cover Magnetic Headcover

Best for: Golfers who want a magnetic closure on a cover that fits a range of mallet putters.

This cover is for players who prefer a magnetic closure and a broader fit across mallet heads, including Scotty Cameron and other mallet brands.

Key specs

• Magnetic closure
• Mallet putter fit
• Fits a range of brands

Pros

• Magnetic closure keeps the cover secure
• Works across several mallet brands
• Easy to remove between shots

Cons

• Universal fit may be less snug than model-specific covers
• Not an authentic Scotty Cameron product

Bottom line: A good choice for owners who want a magnetic, multi-brand mallet cover.

View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover

Best for: Heel shaft mallet putter owners on a budget.

This cover is designed for heel shaft putters, including Scotty Cameron Odyssey-style heads, and suits golfers who want a lower-cost option without sacrificing basic protection.

Key specs

• Designed for heel shaft putters
• Mallet putter profile
• Budget-oriented design

Pros

• Clear heel shaft compatibility
• Budget-friendly choice
• Simple, protective design

Cons

• Not an authentic Scotty Cameron product
• Fewer finish and styling options

Bottom line: The practical pick for heel shaft mallet owners who want basic protection at a lower cost.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Shaft Type: Center vs Heel

The shaft connection is the first thing to check. Center shaft heads and heel shaft heads have different shapes around the hosel, and a cover built for one often sits loosely on the other. Check your putter’s shaft position before you look at any other feature.

Good picks for this: Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover, Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover

Model Compatibility

Scotty Cameron releases many head models, and sizing varies between generations. Match the cover to your exact model name, such as Futura, Phantom X, or a mid-mallet style, rather than just the brand. Listings that name specific models are easier to verify.

Good picks for this: Scotty Cameron Authentic Putter Headcover – Futura, Phantom X, New Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover

Closure Type: Magnetic vs Strap

Magnetic closures let you pull the cover on and off quickly and tend to stay put during a swing. Strap or snap closures can hold tighter but take longer to remove. Choose based on how often you swap putters or clean the head.

Good picks for this: USA Mallet Putter Cover Magnetic Headcover, Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover

Head Shape and Profile

Mid mallets, full mallets and wide profiles differ in depth and footprint. A cover that is too shallow will leave the face exposed, and one that is too deep can rattle. Compare your head’s depth and width to the listing before buying.

Good picks for this: New Scotty Cameron Gray MID Mallet Cover Putter Headcover, New Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover

Authentic vs Universal Fit

Authentic-listed covers are usually made to match a specific brand’s head shape, which often gives a snugger fit. Universal covers cost less and fit more heads but can feel looser. Decide whether a close match or flexibility matters more for your bag.

Good picks for this: New Scotty Cameron Gray MID Mallet Cover Putter Headcover, USA Mallet Putter Cover Magnetic Headcover

Material and Durability

Covers are usually made from synthetic leather, nylon or similar materials. Look for reinforced stitching around the hosel opening and a lining that won’t scratch a finished face. Owners often report that thicker materials hold their shape longer after repeated use.

Good picks for this: Scotty Cameron Authentic Putter Headcover – Futura, Phantom X, Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover

Care and Maintenance

Keep covers dry and clean, and avoid storing them in a damp bag for long periods. Wipe off grass and sand before putting the cover on, since trapped grit can scratch the finish underneath. Check the magnetic closure occasionally if you use one.

Good picks for this: USA Mallet Putter Cover Magnetic Headcover, New Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover

FAQ

Do Scotty Cameron mallet putter covers fit all mallet putters?

No. Most Scotty Cameron covers are built around specific head shapes and shaft positions. Universal covers fit a wider range but may be looser. Check the model name and shaft type before buying.

What is the difference between a center shaft and heel shaft cover?

A center shaft cover has an opening sized for a shaft that enters the head in the middle. A heel shaft cover is shaped for a shaft that connects near the heel. Using the wrong type can leave the cover loose or misshapen.

Are magnetic mallet putter covers secure during a round?

Magnetic covers are designed to stay closed during a round, and owners generally report that they hold well. Check the magnet placement on your specific cover, and make sure the head is dry before putting it on.

How do I measure my putter to choose the right cover?

Measure the head’s depth from the face to the back, and the width across the toe to the heel. Compare these figures with the listing, and confirm the shaft position. If your measurements fall between two sizes, the larger cover is often the safer option.

Can I use a blade putter cover on a mallet?

Generally no. Blade covers are shaped for thin, flat heads and will not fit the deeper shape of a mallet. Use a cover labeled for mallet or mid-mallet heads.

Do authentic Scotty Cameron covers last longer than universal ones?

Owners often report that authentic covers feel more consistent in fit and finish, but durability depends on material and care. Both types can last well with regular cleaning and dry storage.

Should I replace a worn headcover?

Yes, if the closure no longer holds, the lining is worn through, or the cover no longer fits snugly. A worn cover can allow the face to rub against other clubs, which may scratch the finish.

Conclusion

For most Scotty Cameron mallet owners, the 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover is the strongest starting point if you have a center shaft mid mallet, because the fit is model-specific. Right-handed Futura and Phantom X owners should look at the multi-model Authentic listing, while newer mid-mallet owners will find the Style 2025 cover the most natural match. Those who want a magnetic closure across several brands should consider the USA Mallet magnetic option, and heel shaft owners on a budget will find the Craftsman cover practical. Confirm your shaft type and head model before you buy.

Sources

• Official rules and equipment guidance for golf clubs, including how club design is regulated
• Background on putter design and fitting concepts

Related reading

• Scotty Cameron Putter Cover Blade Review: Who Is It For?
• 6 Best Mid Mallet Putter Covers for Every Golfer (2026)
• 6 Best Mallet Head Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)
• 6 Best Mallet Golf Putter Covers for Every Golfer (2026)
• 4 Best Center Shafted Mallet Putter Covers for DF3 Putters (2026)

About the author