We research and compare products using published specifications, features and owner feedback. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more›

5 Best Leather Mid Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)

Compare the best leather mid mallet putter covers for magnetic closure, fit, and durability. See five picks and a buying guide to find the right headcover.

5 Best Leather Mid Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)

Updated November 2026

Choosing a leather mid mallet putter cover comes down to four things: how well it fits the head, how the closure holds, how the leather handles wear, and whether it protects the face and sightline. The five options below were compared using product listings, brand reputation, and patterns in owner feedback, not hands-on testing. Each one is matched to a specific need so you can narrow the field quickly.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Small Mallet Putter Cover Strong MagneticTOP CHOICEBest overallShamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Small Mallet Putter Cover Strong MagneticView on Amazon
  2. 2Barudan Golf Black Putter Headcover Covers Cover for Blade Style PuttersTOP CHOICEBest for magnetic closureBarudan Golf Black Putter Headcover Covers Cover for Blade Style PuttersView on Amazon
  3. 3USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head CoverTOP CHOICEBest for patriotic styleUSA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head CoverView on Amazon
  4. 4Craftsman Golf Luxury Black Premium Leather Golf Club Blade Mallet Putter CoverBest for a premium lookCraftsman Golf Luxury Black Premium Leather Golf Club Blade Mallet Putter CoverView on Amazon
  5. 5Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, BlueBest for center-shaft puttersGolf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, BlueView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Everyday all-round use Strong magnetic, waterproof PU leather
Barudan Golf Black Putter Headcover Quick on-off changes Built-in magnet closure
USA Stars and Stripes Mid Mallet Cover Standout visual style Printed flag design, magnetic closure
Craftsman Golf Luxury Black Leather Cover Classic premium appearance Black premium leather build
Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Cover Center-shaft mallet heads Soft leather with embroidery

Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Small Mallet Putter Cover Strong Magnetic

Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Small Mallet Putter Cover Strong Magnetic | Black Pu Leather Waterproof Clover Half Mallet Putter Headcover For Scotty Cameron Odyssey Ping Putters

Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover Small Mallet Putter Cover Strong Magnetic | Black Pu Leather Waterproof Clover Half Mallet Putter Headcover For Scotty Cameron Odyssey Ping Putters

View on Amazon

Best for: Everyday all-round use

This is a sensible first choice for golfers who want a dependable cover that works across several mallet brands and needs little thought on the course.

Pros

  • Strong magnetic closure keeps the cover secure during the round.
  • Waterproof PU leather handles damp conditions well.

Cons

  • Sizing is built for mid and small mallets, so check your head dimensions first.
View on Amazon

Barudan Golf Black Putter Headcover Covers Cover for Blade Style Putters

Barudan Golf Black Putter Headcover Covers Cover for Blade Style Putters, Magnetic USA Flag Blade Putter Headcovers with Magnet for Men (Red USA (Mallet))

Barudan Golf Black Putter Headcover Covers Cover for Blade Style Putters, Magnetic USA Flag Blade Putter Headcovers with Magnet for Men (Red USA (Mallet))

View on Amazon

Best for: Quick on-off changes

Players who swap covers often or want a simple, low-fuss closure will appreciate the magnetic design.

Pros

  • Magnet closure makes removal and replacement fast.
  • Black finish suits most bag setups.

Cons

  • Listing is styled for blade putters, so confirm fit on a mallet head before buying.
View on Amazon

USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head Cover

USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head Cover | Half/Small Mallet Putter Head Cover, Fit most golf brands, Magnetic Closure

USA Stars and Stripes Print Golf Club Mid Mallet Putter Head Cover | Half/Small Mallet Putter Head Cover, Fit most golf brands, Magnetic Closure

View on Amazon

Best for: Standout visual style

This cover suits golfers who want their putter to stand out in the bag and don’t mind a bold print.

Pros

  • Flag print gives a distinctive look.
  • Magnetic closure is listed as a fit-most design for half and small mallets.

Cons

  • Printed finish is less traditional than solid leather.
View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf Luxury Black Premium Leather Golf Club Blade Mallet Putter Cover

Craftsman Golf Luxury Black Premium Leather Golf Club Blade Mallet Putter Cover Driver Headcover (for Mallet Putter)

Craftsman Golf Luxury Black Premium Leather Golf Club Blade Mallet Putter Cover Driver Headcover (for Mallet Putter)

View on Amazon

Best for: Classic premium appearance

Golfers who prefer a clean, understated black leather look will find this one matches the feel they expect from a traditional headcover.

Pros

  • Premium black leather gives a refined appearance.
  • Listed for both blade and mallet putters, adding flexibility.

Cons

  • Leather needs occasional conditioning to keep its finish.
View on Amazon

Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, Blue

Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, Blue | Center Shaft Mid/Half/Small Mallet Cover, Magnetic Closure, Soft Leather, With Embroidery, Fit Most Brands

Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover, Blue | Center Shaft Mid/Half/Small Mallet Cover, Magnetic Closure, Soft Leather, With Embroidery, Fit Most Brands

View on Amazon

Best for: Center-shaft mallet heads

This is aimed at players whose putter has a center-shaft connection, where a standard heel-shaft cover can sit awkwardly.

Pros

  • Soft leather with embroidery adds a personal touch.
  • Magnetic closure is listed for mid and half mallet sizes.

Cons

  • Blue colorway may not suit golfers wanting a neutral bag look.
View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Confirm the head size and shaft position

Measure the head length and width before buying, since mid and half mallet listings overlap. Shaft position matters too: center-shaft putters need a cover designed for that connection.

Check the closure type

Magnetic closures are quick to use and hold well when the magnet is strong. Snap or hook closures can be more secure but take longer to fasten during a round.

Look at the leather and finish

Full-grain or soft leather usually feels better on the hand and ages well, while PU leather resists moisture more readily. Pick the material that matches your climate and how often you play in wet weather.

Consider the sightline and face protection

The cover should leave the putter face and alignment aid fully protected without hiding the sightline you use to set up. Check that the opening sits correctly over the head before committing.

Good picks for this: Shamrock Mid Mallet Putter Cover and Golf Club Center Shaft Mid/Half Mallet Putter Head Cover

FAQ

Will a leather mid mallet putter cover fit a full-size mallet?

Usually not. Mid and half mallet covers are sized for smaller heads, so a full-size mallet will likely be too large and may not close securely.

Owen Palmer

About Owen Palmer

Owen Palmer is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our putting & short game guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.

About the author

Owen Palmer
Owen Palmer

Owen Palmer writes reviews and buying guides for Putting For Par.