6 Best Masters Mallet Putter Cover Options for Every Stroke (2026)

Updated November 2026

Finding the right masters mallet putter cover comes down to three things: whether it fits your specific head shape, whether the closure keeps it secure through a round, and whether it protects the face and paint without getting in the way when you take it on and off. This guide compares six headcovers built for mallet putters, with a focus on fit, closure type, material and general durability. Our selection method is research-based: we looked at manufacturer specifications, brand reputation and the patterns owners commonly report about fit and wear. We did not test these products ourselves, so treat the notes below as informed comparisons rather than hands-on results.

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product	Best for	Key feature
Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover	Golfers wanting a simple, universal fit	Green mallet headcover for general mallet heads
Golf Putter Covers DF3 Mallet Putter Headcover	Owners of DF3-style mallet putters	Magnetic closure with embroidered detailing
SHABIER Golf Large Mallet Headcover	Golfers with larger mallet heads	Magnetic closure with a bold graphic design
Craftsman Golf Mallet Putter Headcover Green and White Checkered	Golfers who want a classic checkered look	Magnetic closure in a green and white pattern
Team Golf NFL Green Bay Packers Mallet Putter Cover	Packers fans	Licensed team design fitting most mallet brands
Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover	Heel-shafted putters, including Scotty Cameron and Odyssey	Designed for heel-shaft mallet heads

Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover Blade Putter Covers

Best for: Best overall

This is a good starting point for golfers who want a plain, easy-to-use cover that works with a range of mallet heads without a lot of extras to think about.

Key specs

• Designed for mallet putter heads
• Green colorway, as stated in the listing

Pros

• Simple design that is easy to slide on and off
• Works across a variety of mallet shapes
• Low-profile look that suits most bags

Cons

• Fit can vary on unusually large or unusually compact heads
• Limited decorative detail for golfers who want a statement look

Bottom line: A sensible default for most mallet owners who want a clean, no-fuss cover.

View on Amazon

Golf Putter Covers DF3 Mallet Putter Headcover with Magnetic Closure

Best for: Best for DF3 putters

Aimed at golfers using DF3-style mallet putters who want a cover sized and shaped for that head profile and a closure that stays put.

Key specs

• Designed for DF3 mallet putter heads
• Magnetic closure
• Embroidered detailing

Pros

• Model-specific shaping improves fit
• Magnetic closure is quick to use
• Embroidery adds a finished, premium look

Cons

• Narrow fit focus means it may not suit other head shapes
• Embroidery can show wear with frequent handling

Bottom line: The right choice if your putter is a DF3 and fit matters more than universal compatibility.

View on Amazon

SHABIER Golf Large Mallet Headcover for Golf Putter Club

Best for: Best for a bold look

Suited to golfers who want a larger cover with a distinctive graphic design and a magnetic closure to keep it in place during a round.

Key specs

• Large mallet headcover format
• Magnetic closure
• Decorative graphic design

Pros

• Generous sizing suits bigger mallet heads
• Magnetic closure holds firmly
• Stands out in the bag

Cons

• Oversized fit can look loose on compact heads
• Bold design may not suit a minimalist bag

Bottom line: Best for golfers with larger mallets who want their cover to make a statement.

View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf Club Cover Mallet Putter Headcover Green and White Checkered

Best for: Best for checkered style

A good fit for golfers who want a classic, traditional look with a closure that is easy to fasten and release.

Key specs

• Green and white checkered pattern
• Magnetic closure
• Mallet putter format

Pros

• Classic pattern suits a wide range of bags
• Magnetic closure is convenient mid-round
• Easy to identify on the course

Cons

• Pattern shows dirt more quickly than solid colors
• Fit is general rather than model-specific

Bottom line: A strong choice for golfers who prefer a traditional, recognizable style.

View on Amazon

Team Golf NFL Green Bay Packers Golf Mallet Putter Cover

Best for: Best for team fans

Designed for golfers who want to show team pride, with a licensed design and a cover intended to fit a broad range of mallet putter brands.

Key specs

• Licensed NFL Green Bay Packers design
• Listed as fitting most mallet putters

Pros

• Clear team identity for fans
• Universal-style fit across several brands
• Makes a fun conversation piece on the course

Cons

• Universal fit can be looser on some heads
• Team design limits appeal for non-fans

Bottom line: The obvious pick for Packers fans who want their putter to match their allegiance.

View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover

Best for: Best for heel-shafted putters

Intended for golfers with heel-shafted mallet putters, where head orientation and shaft position make a generic cover less secure.

Key specs

• Designed for heel-shaft mallet putters
• Patriotic America design

Pros

• Heel-shaft fit improves security
• Distinctive design
• Protects the face and paint in the bag

Cons

• Not suited to center-shafted putters
• Design may not suit every bag

Bottom line: A targeted choice for heel-shafted putter owners who want a cover shaped for that setup.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Head shape and model fit

Mallet heads vary widely in depth, width and toe-to-heel length. Before buying, measure your head from the leading edge to the back and from heel to toe. A cover that is too tight can tear at the seams, while a loose one may slip off during a swing or on a cart ride. Model-specific covers, such as those labeled for DF3 heads, usually give the most secure fit.

Good picks for this: Golf Putter Covers DF3 Mallet Putter Headcover, Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover

Shaft position: center versus heel

Center-shafted and heel-shafted putters sit differently in a cover. Heel-shaft designs often need a cover shaped to accommodate the shaft entry point. Check the product description for shaft compatibility before ordering, since a mismatch is one of the most common reasons owners return a cover.

Good picks for this: Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover

Closure type

Most mallet covers use either a magnetic closure or a hook-and-loop or elastic closure. Magnetic closures are quick and tend to hold well, but they should be kept away from magnetic-sensitive items. Owners often prefer magnets for speed on the course.

Good picks for this: SHABIER Golf Large Mallet Headcover, Craftsman Golf Club Cover Mallet Putter Headcover Green and White Checkered

Size and head coverage

Larger heads need larger covers, and a generous cover on a compact head can look baggy and move around. Think about how much of the face you want protected. Full coverage is generally better for protecting the paint and the face from bag contact.

Good picks for this: SHABIER Golf Large Mallet Headcover

Material and durability

Covers are usually made from synthetic leather, nylon or embroidered fabric. Synthetic leather is typically easier to wipe clean, while embroidered designs can show wear sooner with frequent handling. Look for stitching that appears even and reinforced at stress points.

Good picks for this: Golf Putter Covers DF3 Mallet Putter Headcover, Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover

Design and visibility on the course

Colors and patterns help you identify your putter quickly, especially when several players in a group carry similar bags. Bold or team designs make a cover easy to spot, while solid or checkered patterns offer a more understated look.

Good picks for this: Team Golf NFL Green Bay Packers Golf Mallet Putter Cover, Craftsman Golf Club Cover Mallet Putter Headcover Green and White Checkered

Care and maintenance

Keep covers dry and remove grass, sand or dirt before storing them. Wipe synthetic materials with a damp cloth and let them air dry away from direct heat. Avoid soaking embroidered designs. Check magnets and closures periodically to make sure they still hold firmly.

Good picks for this: Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover, Montela Golf Putter Covers Mallet Putter Headcover

FAQ

What is a masters mallet putter cover?

A masters mallet putter cover is a protective headcover designed for mallet-style putters. The name is used broadly in product listings, so check the specific fit and shaft compatibility of any cover before buying.

How do I know what size mallet cover I need?

Measure the length and depth of your putter head and compare those numbers with the dimensions in the product listing. If the manufacturer lists a model fit, such as a DF3 cover for a DF3 head, that is usually the most reliable guide.

Do magnetic closures damage putters?

Magnetic closures are generally considered safe for golf clubs, but keep magnetic covers away from phones, credit cards and other magnetic-sensitive items. If you have concerns about a specific product, check with the manufacturer.

Can I use a universal mallet cover on any putter?

Universal covers can fit many heads, but they may be looser or tighter than a model-specific cover. For the most secure fit, choose a cover that lists your exact head model.

Will a headcover protect my putter in a golf bag?

A well-fitting headcover reduces contact between the putter face and other clubs, which helps protect the finish and face. It cannot prevent all damage from rough handling, so keep the bag organized.

How should I clean a golf putter cover?

Brush off loose dirt, then wipe with a damp cloth and mild soap if needed. Let the cover dry completely before storing it, and avoid soaking embroidered or decorative designs.

Conclusion

For most mallet owners, the Montela cover is a sensible all-around choice because of its simple fit and easy use. If you own a DF3 putter, the model-specific DF3 cover makes the most sense. Golfers who want a bigger statement should look at the SHABIER large design, while those who prefer a classic look may prefer the checkered Craftsman cover. Team fans will naturally gravitate toward the Packers design, and owners of heel-shafted putters should choose the Craftsman America cover for its targeted fit. Measure your head before you buy, and confirm shaft compatibility to avoid returns.

Sources

• Official rules and equipment standards for golf clubs, including guidance relevant to putter design
• Consumer product safety information on magnets and small magnetic components (cpsc.gov)

Related reading

• 7 Best Magnetic Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)
• 6 Best TaylorMade Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)
• 6 Best Scotty Cameron Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)
• 6 Best Mid Mallet Putter Covers for Every Golfer (2026)
• 6 Best Mallet Head Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)

About the author