7 Best Scotty Cameron Mid Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)

Updated November 2026

Shopping for a scotty cameron mid mallet putter cover means matching three things: the putter’s shape, the shaft position, and the way you want to protect the face and finish. This guide ranks seven options by fit with a mid mallet head, shaft style (heel or center), protection, and how well each design matches common owner feedback. Every pick is an Amazon listing, and each entry notes what the product is built for and where it falls short.

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product	Best for	Key feature
Scotty Cameron Gray MID Mallet Cover	Universal mid mallet fit	Gray colorway, listed as universal
Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover	Current mid mallet heads	Mid-mallet silhouette, not blade style
Scotty Cameron 2020 Special Select Red Headcover	Collectors and display	Special Select styling in red
Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover	Center shaft putters	Center shaft design
Scotty Cameron Authentic Futura / Phantom X Headcover	Futura and Phantom X heads	Mid round, right-handed
Scotty Cameron Phantom X Mid-Round Headcover	Black finish, right-handed players	Black, mid round
Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Headcover	Heel shaft mallets on a budget	Designed for heel shaft

New Scotty Cameron Gray MID Mallet Cover Putter Headcover – Universal & Authentic

Best for: Players who want a single mid mallet cover that fits a range of heads.

This is a good starting point for golfers with a mid mallet who do not want to match a specific model. The listing describes it as universal, so it suits owners who switch between heads or who are unsure of their exact model.

Key specs

• Mid mallet silhouette
• Gray colorway
• Listed as universal fit

Pros

• Versatile fit across several mid mallet heads
• Neutral gray color hides wear better than bright colors
• Simple, understated look

Cons

• Universal sizing can feel looser than a model-matched cover
• Owners who want a specific model may prefer a dedicated fit

Bottom line: A strong default for mid mallet owners who want one cover that works across heads.

View on Amazon

New Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover (Not Blade Style) – 100% Authentic

Best for: Owners of recent mid mallet models who want a current-style cover.

The listing states it is a mid-mallet design and specifically not blade style, which helps avoid the common mistake of buying a blade cover for a mallet head. It is aimed at players whose putter is a newer mid mallet.

Key specs

• Mid-mallet design
• Style 2025 release, per listing name
• Listed as authentic

Pros

• Clearly labeled as mid-mallet, not blade
• Matches a current-generation Scotty Cameron look
• Helpful for avoiding blade-shaped covers that do not fit

Cons

• Fit is designed around a specific style, so older heads may not match
• Limited to owners of the 2025-style mallet

Bottom line: The right choice if your putter is a recent Scotty Cameron mid mallet and you want the matching silhouette.

View on Amazon

Scotty Cameron 2020 Special Select Putter Red Headcover – Mid Mallet (Not Blade)

Best for: Collectors and golfers who want a bold red look on a mid mallet.

This cover comes from the Special Select line, which many owners treat as a collectible tier. It is labeled mid mallet and not blade, so the fit is clear. It suits players who want the cover to be part of the putter’s identity.

Key specs

• Mid mallet design
• Special Select 2020 release, per listing name
• Red colorway

Pros

• Eye-catching red finish that is easy to find in a bag
• Collectible appeal for Special Select fans
• Clearly marked as mid mallet

Cons

• Bright color shows scuffs and dirt more quickly
• Older release may be harder to match with current heads

Bottom line: A good pick for golfers who value style and collectibility as much as protection.

View on Amazon

Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover

Best for: Owners of center shaft mid mallet putters.

The listing specifies center shaft only, so this cover is built for putters where the shaft enters the center of the head. Anyone with a heel-shafted mallet should look at the other options here instead.

Key specs

• Mid mallet design
• Center shaft fit only
• Black, gray, and red colorway, per listing name

Pros

• Built specifically for center shaft mallets
• Multi-color design fits a range of setups
• Current Phantom styling

Cons

• Will not fit heel shaft putters
• Multi-color pattern can look busy on some heads

Bottom line: The best match for a center shaft Phantom-style mid mallet, as long as you confirm your shaft position first.

View on Amazon

Scotty Cameron Authentic Putter Headcover – Futura, Phantom X – X7, 5.5M, 5W, 7M, Headcover – MID Round (Right Handed)

Best for: Right-handed players with Futura or Phantom X mid round heads.

The listing names several head models and specifies mid round and right-handed, which makes it useful for owners who want to match a specific Futura or Phantom X model rather than a generic cover.

Key specs

• Mid round shape
• Right-handed orientation
• Listed for Futura and Phantom X models, including X7 and 5.5M per listing name

Pros

• Model-specific listing reduces fit guesswork
• Clearly labeled handedness and shape
• Covers multiple Futura and Phantom X variants

Cons

• Fit only works if your model is on the list
• Not suitable for left-handed setups

Bottom line: The right choice for right-handed Futura or Phantom X owners who want an exact-model match.

View on Amazon

Scotty Cameron Phantom X Mid-Round Putter Headcover – Black, Right Hand

Best for: Right-handed players who prefer a black mid round cover.

This option is a clean black mid round cover for right-handed Phantom X putters. Its plain color suits golfers who want a low-profile look that matches most bag setups.

Key specs

• Phantom X line
• Mid round shape
• Black colorway, right-hand orientation

Pros

• Black finish hides dirt and wear
• Clearly labeled for right-handed use
• Simple design blends with most putters

Cons

• Plain styling offers less visual appeal than multi-color options
• Right-hand only, so left-handed golfers need another pick

Bottom line: A practical, low-maintenance choice for right-handed Phantom X mid round owners.

View on Amazon

Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover Headcover for Scotty Cameron Odyssey (for Heel Shaft)

Best for: Budget-minded golfers with heel shaft mallets.

This is a third-party cover designed for heel shaft mallets, including Odyssey-style heads that golfers often pair with Scotty Cameron-style protection. It is a budget pick for players who want a functional cover without premium branding.

Key specs

• Mallet putter design
• Heel shaft fit
• Third-party, non-Scotty Cameron brand

Pros

• Budget-friendly way to protect a heel shaft mallet
• Explicitly built for heel shaft fit
• Works as a straightforward replacement cover

Cons

• Not an official Scotty Cameron product
• Build and finish may not match premium branded covers

Bottom line: A sensible choice for heel shaft mallet owners who want protection without a branded price tag.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Shaft position: heel or center

Check where the shaft attaches before buying anything. Center shaft putters need a cover with a center shaft opening, while heel shaft putters need a cover built for that position. A mismatch causes the cover to sit crooked or not fit at all.

Good picks for this: Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover, Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover (heel shaft)

Head model and style year

Mid mallet heads vary by release year and line, such as Futura, Phantom X, and newer Phantom designs. Matching the listed model name reduces the chance of a loose or tight fit. Use your putter’s stamping or original documentation to confirm the model.

Good picks for this: Scotty Cameron Authentic Futura / Phantom X Headcover, New Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover

Handedness

Many covers are listed for right-handed use only. Confirm your orientation before ordering, since a left-handed putter may need a different design or a left-handed listing.

Good picks for this: Scotty Cameron Phantom X Mid-Round Putter Headcover, Scotty Cameron Authentic Futura / Phantom X Headcover

Fit and snugness

A cover that is too loose can slip off during the walk, while one that is too tight can be hard to remove. Universal covers offer flexibility, but model-specific covers usually sit more securely. Test the fit by sliding the cover on and off the head before you head to the course.

Good picks for this: New Scotty Cameron Gray MID Mallet Cover Putter Headcover, Scotty Cameron Authentic Futura / Phantom X Headcover

Color and visibility

Bright colors such as red make the putter easy to spot in a bag, while black and gray hide dirt and everyday scuffs. Choose based on whether you want the cover to stand out or blend in.

Good picks for this: Scotty Cameron 2020 Special Select Red Headcover, Scotty Cameron Phantom X Mid-Round Putter Headcover (black)

Material and durability

Synthetic leather and similar materials resist moisture and wear better than thin fabrics. Owners often report that covers stored in a hot car or left wet can crack or fade over time. Store the cover in a dry bag and avoid leaving it in direct sun.

Good picks for this: New Scotty Cameron Style 2025 Mid-Mallet Headcover, Craftsman Golf USA America Mallet Putter Cover

Care and maintenance

Wipe the cover with a damp cloth after rounds and let it air dry away from heat. Check the manufacturer’s care instructions before using any cleaner, since some finishes react poorly to harsh solvents.

Good picks for this: Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft Headcover, Scotty Cameron Authentic Futura / Phantom X Headcover

FAQ

Will a Scotty Cameron mid mallet cover fit any mallet putter?

Not always. Some covers are universal, but many are built for specific head shapes and shaft positions. Confirm the listing’s fit notes against your putter before buying.

What is the difference between a mid mallet and a blade cover?

Mid mallet covers are shaped for a larger, rounder head, while blade covers fit a thinner, traditional head. Using the wrong style usually leaves the cover loose or unable to fit at all.

How do I know if my putter is center shaft or heel shaft?

Look at where the shaft meets the head. Center shaft putters have the shaft attached at the middle of the head, while heel shaft putters attach near the heel end. The model stamping or your original purchase documentation can also confirm this.

Do I need a left-handed cover if I play left-handed?

Yes, if the cover is listed as right-handed only. Check the handedness in the listing before ordering, since some covers do not have a left-handed version.

Are universal covers as secure as model-specific covers?

Universal covers can work well, but a model-specific cover usually sits more snugly. If the fit feels loose, a dedicated model listing may be the better option.

How should I clean a putter cover?

Wipe it with a damp cloth and let it air dry. Avoid soaking it or using harsh chemicals, and check the care guidance from the manufacturer for finish-specific advice.

Can a cover damage the putter finish?

A clean, properly fitted cover protects the head. Grit trapped inside a cover can scratch the finish, so keep the cover clean and remove sand or dirt before sliding it on.

Conclusion

For most mid mallet owners, the New Scotty Cameron Gray MID Mallet Cover is a reasonable default because it is listed as universal. If you own a recent mid mallet, the Style 2025 cover matches the current silhouette. Center shaft owners should choose the Phantom Mid Mallet Center Shaft cover, while Futura and Phantom X owners should look at the model-specific listings. Heel shaft golfers on a budget can consider the Craftsman option. Always confirm shaft position, handedness, and head model before you buy.

Sources

• Official rules and equipment standards for golf clubs and related equipment
• Standards and measurement guidance for materials and product durability (nist.gov)
• Consumer product safety information relevant to everyday sporting goods (cpsc.gov)

Related reading

• 6 Best Scotty Cameron Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)
• 6 Best Mid Mallet Putter Covers for Every Golfer (2026)
• Scotty Cameron Putter Cover Blade Review: Who Is It For?
• 7 Best Magnetic Mallet Putter Covers for Every Stroke (2026)

About the author